Vaccination Requirements in the Workplace

September 29, 2021

Yellow connected circles and lines forming a simple network diagram on a white background

As vaccination rates rise around New Zealand, and discussion grows around changing alert levels and introducing different Covid controls, I am getting more questions from employers around their rights and obligations around vaccination. In particular, whether an employer can make it a requirement to be vaccinated for an employee to gain or maintain their employment.


There is no doubt Covid 19 is impacting our society, both directly with people being infected by Covid 19 and indirectly via lockdowns and job losses, etc. We are constantly reminded that we need to all play our part and get vaccinated.


Now, this blog isn't a debate on the merits of vaccinations. However, I see some media reports indicating that some businesses are following an overseas model of only allowing vaccinated people to enter their premises. I won't dwell on the legalities of that stance, but it does seem many companies are asking for a simple yes or no answer as to whether they can make it mandatory for their employees to be vaccinated. No one can give that to you, and if they do, I would be very sceptical of that advice.


At present, Health Orders have mandated that all border workers who either work at the border or one of our MIQ facilities must be vaccinated and tested regularly. That order (to date) does not require that of employees at any other workplace.


Therefore, the legislation that applies to all other employers and employees regarding vaccination is the Employment Relations Act 2000 and the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015. These acts have not been changed as a result of Covid 19, as some employers found out when they decided to reduce employee's wages without the proper process during lockdowns.


The Employment Relations Act 2000 still states that any decision made by the employer must be what a fair and reasonable employer could do in all the circumstances. Furthermore, for any decision that is likely to impact an employee's employment status, the employer must first provide all the relevant information and then allow the employees to respond to any proposal before making any decision. That is a very high bar to reach and not something that should be taken for granted.


When it comes to Health and Safety, as an employer, you're responsible for maintaining a safe workplace and taking reasonable action/steps to mitigate any reasonable risk of harm to employees. Now I'm not an outright expert on Health and Safety matters, but one of the basic steps to making any significant health and safety decision is that there needs to be a full Health and Safety Risk Assessment. We use the superstars at Manage Group for all the finer aspects of H&S, who can help businesses with this.


So, when it comes to making Health and Safety decisions around Covid 19, one of the first steps is to make a realistic assessment of the risk your employees face in the current Covid 19 environment.


What does that look like? Well, let's take a look at our awesome Custom Officers at the airport. As they process passengers from overseas, what are the realistic risks of coming into contact with Covid 19? You only have to watch the daily briefings from our Director General of Health to know that many people are arriving into our country, then testing positive for Covid 19 in MIQ. I don't think many that would argue that under the risk assessment matrix, it is probable (if not certain) that our Customs Officers will come into contact with someone that has been infected with Covid 19.


The next step is to determine what the impact would be of a Customs Officer contracting Covid 19 from one of these passengers. Again, we can just look at the impact of the virus getting into the community as we continue to navigate continued infections and raised alert levels across New Zealand. There is the societal impact of lockdowns and restrictions and the health impact on people who contract the virus. Again, I'm not taking a position on the seriousness of the virus; I am merely suggesting an employer must take a "reasoned" approach to these topics.


So, for the sake of this conversation, let's just agree that there is a serious risk of Covid exposure in this particular workplace. We can now look at the obligations of the employer to mitigate this risk in their workplace and what options are open to them:


  • Policy on social distancing?
  • Wearing masks/gloves?
  • Wearing PPE with higher levels of protection?
  • Vaccination?
  • All or some of the above?


A decision like this needs to be practical in the circumstances, and that practicality will be dependent on the risk. By this, I mean we need to weigh up the risk versus what is reasonable. Do we require our builders to wear a harness if they are working 1m off the ground? No. Is there a risk that the builder may fall 1m and hurt themselves? Of course there is, but the risk is relatively low, so the mitigation needs to be proportionate to the risk.


Now we turn to vaccination. By making it mandatory to be vaccinated in your workplace, you are essentially forcing your staff to undergo a medical procedure for the purposes of their employment. Now when you put it like that, things have just got serious. The question that needs to be asked is, is it reasonable to force your employees to be vaccinated after considering all factors?


Now for our border workers, there may be a solid argument there that because of the level of exposure they could potentially face every day, social distancing and PPE may not be suitable enough to mitigate the risk, and thus for people who deal with passengers, vaccination may be required (obviously it is required under the Health Act for front line workers at the border, but the risk assessment should be the same approach).


Now let's look at an office worker. For this example, in our current Covid 19 environment with the Government's elimination strategy, what is the likelihood of that worker contracting Covid 19? To help you answer this question, at the time of writing this, since Feb 2020, NZ has had just over 3,500 people infected with Covid. From a population percentage point of view, that is 0.07% of the population (based on a population of 5m). Turning that around, some could argue that is a 99.93% chance of not catching it.


So let's go back to that risk assessment. The risk of an office worker contracting Covid via their employment is minuscule compared to a Customs Officer. Taking my example of the builder, is it reasonable to force someone to undergo a medical procedure that comes with its own set of potential risks, including serious side effects or even death? Or would it be more reasonable to think that you could mitigate that small risk by adopting some of the other policies?


Now, this process is only relevant to our current situation. If our borders reopen or the Government ditches the "elimination" strategy, that risk assessment may change depending on what's happening. That is why it is not a simple yes or no question in the broader sense of the term.


There are several cases before the Authority/Courts that will give us some more guidance on the issue, and I know my friends in the industry and I are watching very closely as to what is determined as "reasonable".


In the meantime, if you need more individual advice on the matter, please do contact me. If you want some advice on risk assessments for your workplace and other Health and Safety issues, contact the Manage Group.


Be safe and be kind.


Disclaimer: The above information is meant to be a broad and informative narrative of the topic. It is not intended to be specific legal advice. If you want specific advice pertaining to your situation, please contact me directly or another trusted Employment Law Specialist.


JOHN DUSTOW

HR Advisory and Employment Law Specialist

E: johnd@recruitit.co.nz | P: 027 855 9989

Recruiter in office with laptop and resume; banner reads “What Your CV Tells Us in 20 Seconds.”
October 9, 2025
We’ve seen it all. Some CVs stand out for the right reasons, some fall flat, and others make us wonder, “What story is this person trying to tell?” Whether you’re a developer in Auckland, a BA in Wellington, or an engineer in Hamilton, your CV is your first handshake with a potential employer. It can open doors or quietly close them before you even get a look-in.
Hand holding a smartphone over a table with a blue and white app screen visible
By Kaleb Leeming • June 2, 2025
When your delivery timelines are tight and your internal team’s at capacity, bringing in a contractor can be a smart, strategic call. Whether you're launching a high-impact initiative or need a specialist skill set fast, contractors provide flexibility without the long-term commitment. But there’s one question we often hear from Programme Managers and Heads of: “What should we be paying?” It’s a fair question, and there’s no blanket answer. Contractor rates in New Zealand vary based on market factors, capability, and demand. So, we’ve outlined a framework to help you confidently assess, benchmark, and negotiate contractor rates that make sense for both your project and your budget. What Drives Contractor Rates? Understanding why rates fluctuate helps you avoid overpaying or underestimating what’s required to attract top-tier talent. Skill set + seniority: High-demand roles like Data Engineering, Cybersecurity, and Data Architecture often command premium rates especially at the senior level. Context into what other projects and driving demand in certain areas, will play into this too. Contract length: Short-term, high-impact engagements typically cost more per day than longer-term delivery roles. Lead time: Need someone to start Monday? You’re likely entering a premium window. Location: While remote work has levelled the field somewhat, rates in Auckland and Wellington still tend to sit higher. Project complexity: The more critical the deliverable, the more value (and risk mitigation) a contractor brings. A Framework for Setting Contractor Rates 1. Benchmark the Market: Platforms like SEEK and Trade Me offer a baseline, but the most current data comes from recruiters placing candidates roles today. Recruit I.T. consultants can share live feedback on what candidates are both accepting and on, along with expectations on durations being offered. 2. Define Business Value: What will this person enable faster delivery? Platform stability? Customer experience uplift? Knowing the business outcome helps justify the investment. 3. Think Beyond the Rate: Flexible hours, remote options, autonomy, type of project, and long-term runway can all influence a contractor’s willingness to move on price. 4. Be Clear on Budget: Early transparency helps us filter for best-fit candidates. We’ll help guide expectations within realistic parameters. 5. Move Decisively: Top contractors won’t wait around. If you’re serious about hiring, clarity and speed go a long way. Common Rate Models Hourly – The most often used, particularly with variable workloads (e.g. $125/hr for a Senior BA) Daily – Second behind hourly rates (e.g. $1000/day for a DevOps Engineer) Project-Based – Scoped deliverables with fixed pricing (e.g. three-month platform migration) Need help choosing the right model? We'll recommend one based on your timeline, delivery method, and risk appetite. When to Flex, and When to Hold Rate negotiations shouldn’t start from a place of minimisation. Instead, anchor your offer in context: Flex when: The skill set is niche or hard to find You need immediate impact The candidate brings experience that de-risks delivery Hold when: The role is longer-term and stable The market is supplying strong candidates and skillsets The proposed rate aligns with market norms A realistic range allows room to move without compromising on delivery or candidate quality. How Recruit I.T. Can Help We support rate-setting conversations with: Real-time contractor market insights Customised advice based on your project scope and urgency Negotiation support that respects both candidate and client value Whether you're hiring one expert or scaling an entire project team, we help you land the right people, at the right price, without delay or confusion. Want to sense-check a contractor rate or discuss your upcoming needs?  Reach out to our Recruit I.T. team today. We’ll help you make a smart, timely, and informed hire.
Recruit-it Technology & Digital Market Update report cover with blue city skyscrapers
By Kaleb Leeming • April 1, 2025
Download our latest Market Update for FREE Our first Market Update for the year 2025 is now available for download! After gathering key insights from the market and from our firsthand experience within NZ’s tech and digital space at present, we are pleased to share with you some valuable data and insights to support your decision-making for your business. To access the Market Update, simply click the button below to download your FREE copy.
Hands typing on a laptop with a blurred analytics dashboard on the screen.
February 18, 2025
If you’re currently looking for opportunities in the tech industry, you’ll need a competitive CV that stands out in a pool of applicants. Keep reading to get a FREE recuiter-approved CV template!
Hand holding glowing digital orb above a laptop with cyber security icons on dark blue screen
By Kaleb Leeming • February 4, 2025
If you search “how to create a CV” on Google, you’ll be bombarded with thousands of results in seconds. But hear us out: this is not your ordinary CV-writing blog. In this article, we'll discuss how to craft the perfect IT contractor CV for today’s evolving tech landscape. If you’re currently looking for opportunities in the tech industry, you’ll need a competitive CV that stands out in a pool of applicants—and that’s exactly what we’ll help you with here. From creating an effective structure to showcasing key skills and experiences with relevant examples, we’ll cover everything so that by the end of this blog, you’ll be able to create a well-crafted IT contractor CV tailored for your next job search. Strengthen Your Employer Brand Your employer brand is your reputation in the market. It’s what candidates hear about you from peers, read online, and feel when they interact with your business. A strong employer brand doesn’t just attract talent—it attracts the RIGHT talent. What Makes a Great Employer Brand? Authenticity: Forget corporate buzzwords—tech professionals value transparency. Share real stories about your company culture, team achievements, and the impact your employees make. Visibility: Update your LinkedIn, website, and careers page with fresh content. Use platforms like Instagram and YouTube to showcase your team and workplace. Data-Driven Insights: Take stock of what your employees and candidates are saying on platforms like Glassdoor. If there’s room for improvement, act on it. Quick Wins for the New Year Post a message on social media celebrating your team’s achievements and 2025 goals. Highlight employee stories—what projects did they love? How have they grown? Refresh your careers page to reflect your company’s values and what candidates can expect. 2. Flexibility Is More Than Remote Work Flexibility has evolved beyond remote vs. in-office work. In 2025, it’s about offering environments where employees can thrive both professionally and personally. Why Flexibility Matters The days of rigid 9-to-5 schedules are over. Candidates now expect: Location flexibility (hybrid or fully remote roles) Schedule flexibility (adjustable start times, compressed workweeks) Career flexibility (lateral moves, cross-training opportunities) How to Get It Right Offer remote and hybrid options—your ideal candidate might prefer working from anywhere in New Zealand. Think beyond location—compressed workweeks, sabbatical options, and asynchronous collaboration will boost retention. Invest in collaboration tools—ensure seamless teamwork, regardless of where employees are based. Pro Tip for 2025: Kick off the year with a team survey to understand what flexibility means to your employees. Use their feedback to shape policies that will attract and retain the right talent. 3. Write Job Descriptions That Sell Your job description is often the first impression candidates have of your company. In a competitive market, a compelling job ad makes all the difference. What Makes a Great Job Description? Clarity Over Complexity: Avoid jargon and exhaustive requirements. Focus on key skills and experiences that matter most. Impact-Focused: Instead of listing tasks, highlight the outcomes and impact of the role. Inclusive Language: Use gender-neutral and welcoming language to ensure your ad resonates with diverse candidates. Highlight Perks: Beyond salary, tech professionals look for growth opportunities, professional development, and work-life balance. Example: Before and After Before: "We’re looking for a highly skilled developer with experience in Python, Java, SQL, React, Node.js, and AWS." After: "Join our team to build cutting-edge cloud solutions that impact thousands of users daily. You’ll work with Python and AWS in a collaborative environment that values learning and innovation." 4. Stay Competitive in a Fast-Changing Market To attract the best talent, you need to stay ahead of the curve. How to Compete Effectively Benchmark Salaries Regularly: Use real-time salary data to ensure competitive but sustainable packages. Think Beyond Pay: Offer benefits that matter, like flexible working arrangements, training budgets, and career progression pathways. Focus on Purpose: Tech professionals want meaningful work. Whether you’re solving real-world problems or leading innovation, make sure candidates understand their impact. New Year Action Plan: Review your salary bands, perks, and progression frameworks. Are you offering what top talent expects in 2025? 5. Leverage Recruitment Expertise Attracting tech talent isn’t easy—but you don’t have to do it alone. Partnering with a specialist recruitment team can save time, reduce stress, and ensure you’re connecting with the best candidates. Why Work with a Recruiter? Market Insights: Recruiters have their finger on the pulse of salary trends, hiring challenges, and candidate expectations. Time Savings: Sourcing and vetting candidates takes time—let a recruitment expert handle it so you can focus on growing your business. Access to Hidden Talent: The best candidates aren’t always actively looking for a job. Recruiters tap into passive talent pools to find hidden gems.  Looking Ahead to a Successful 2025 As we kick off the new year, it’s the perfect time to reflect on your hiring strategy and ensure it’s primed for success. The market may be shifting, but with the right approach, you can position your business as an employer of choice. If you’re ready to take your tech hiring to the next level, we’re here to help. At Recruit I.T., we specialise in connecting New Zealand businesses with exceptional tech talent. Whether you need to refine your employer brand, craft better job ads, or tap into passive talent pools, our team has the expertise to support you. Connect with our team today, and let’s make 2025 your best hiring year yet.
Hands typing on a laptop with digital interface icons on a dark background
By Kaleb Leeming • June 24, 2024
Field at Present: From a Director’s Perspective We have seen a continuation of the slow start to the year, which is expected given the overall economic climate in the market alongside government budgetary pressures. There is certainly an increase in general activity coming in from private companies with an increase in ratios of new hires vs replacements. With the recent budget announcements, we will see the flow on impact across government with both the continuation and kick off of new projects, which in our prediction will see an increase in recruitment activity across the board from July onwards. Although certainly not at the frequency of what we have seen in the last six months, we are still seeing organisations across a range of industries forced into making rounds of redundancies and other operational cuts or changes to help them operate more leanly during challenging times. Middle Management We have seen middle management across the board be impacted, and even those not impacted are mindful of the overall cost pressures, and generally more approachable to opportunities. We have seen organisations consolidate middle management positions, which in a practical sense has seen individuals take on more responsibilities, often without the necessary financial upside to this. It is a common trend as businesses look to operator in a leaner fashion. However, leaders need to be mindful of the impact that can have to burnout and further attrition. Opportunities to Onboard Senior Tech Leaders On the flipside, looking at the opportunities for businesses in terms of people and talent, in some regions, we have seen an increase in senior technology leaders actively in the market due to restructuring and redundancies, along with a number of skilled and experienced leaders passively looking to move on. The numbers are certainly something we haven’t seen in some time. There is some great talent out in the market, and businesses have the opportunity to snap up some exceptional senior leaders to really assist in their technology transformations. Gen AI Not a meeting or interaction goes by without the mention of Gen AI - it is certainly hot on the lips of not only the technology industry but most organisations and industries. Naturally, and for good reason, it is a regular talking point, and the technologies underpinning Gen AI have continued to progress at an unprecedented pace. We are seeing an increase in businesses exploring and adopting Gen AI in many ways, and we foresee the rate of this uptake continuing to increase. The Budget The budget appeared light on tech and digital investment, with the big projects being impacted being the digital transformation at NZ Institute of Skills and Technology (Te Pukenga) and the 3 Waters reform program. For anyone interested in things from a technology perspective we would recommend checking out Rob O’Neils take via Reseller News here. The focus from a technology perspective within government seems to be centered around using technology for operational efficiencies, as opposed to investments in the technology sector and assisting organizations, whether it be with a local or international focus. Overall, there's an increase in infrastructure spend, including digital infrastructure, which will hopefully continue to foster innovation. Key Advice for Jobseekers We have noticed an increase in applications that have not specifically read the contents of the job advertisement and requirements needed. For all candidates, it is important that your specific skills and expertise are aligned so some time tweaking, preparing and tailoring CV or Cover Letter is important to standout in the market. Another tip from us is to have someone from outside your industry to sanity check your CV for you. If they can understand what you do or your core skills, a non-tech savvy generalist HR or recruitment personnel would most likely be able to decipher your CV. Plus, a fresh set of eyes will often pick up small errors or things you may have missed. In relation to CVs, ensure that you have your phone numbers and email addresses on the first page so it will be easier for the recruiter to get in touch. We have had an experience with candidates missing important contact information on their CV, so it’s best to run through yours one last time before sending it out to different recruiters. It will also help to build your personal brand to stand out in a talent-saturated market like NZ’s. This will help recruiters get a better grasp of who you are as an individual and as a candidate for the role. You don’t have to have a huge following, but constantly sharing your learnings and useful stuff with your professional network will help you stand out in an over-saturated market. As always keep connected with your network and recruitment partners. We are certainly seeing an increase in roles being placed off market, so ensuring you stay top of mind with your network will assist in increasing your chances of being in the right place at the right time. A Final Note As we look ahead to what is ahead, we are seeing the term ‘green shoots’ used in the market. This is a term used to describe signs of economic recovery or positive data during an economic downturn. Whilst we are certainly mindful of the wider climate, these so called ‘Green Shoots’ are providing some promise in what we see as continuing tough year ahead. As ever, we are aiming to stay dedicated to nurturing relationships and providing advice and support to both our candidate base and our customers to ensure that are receiving a high-quality service. If you have any questions, or would like any advice regarding hiring talent for your team or business, please reach out to myself, Chris , Bianca , or any of our team members for a confidential discussion.
Overhead view of two people collaborating at a desk with a laptop, papers, and coffee cups
May 21, 2024
Aotearoa’s tech scene has been tricky to navigate lately, with constant changes and economic factors directly affecting the way businesses recruit; and the need for the right recruitment partner has never been more crucial. Companies are in a constant battle to snag the best talent amid the candidate-heavy market, facing off against fierce competition at every turn. Because of this, it’s tempting to cast a wide net and work with multiple recruiters, but let’s talk about the magic of going exclusive. Here's why you should consider going exclusive with a recruitment partner for any roles you’re recruiting for:
Three coworkers smiling and talking at computers in an office workspace
May 12, 2024
So, you’re about to embark on a new adventure in the tech world. Whether you’re diving into the buzzing scene of New Zealand or any other tech hub, starting with a new company can be both thrilling and daunting. But fret not, we’ve got your back with some practical tips to help you navigate those early days with ease, no matter where you land.
Red bow tie on a white dog collar among blurred white spools on a blue background
March 27, 2024
Entering the job market after many years can be a daunting task, especially in the fast-paced world of IT and Technology. With advancements happening at breakneck speed, it is understandable to feel overwhelmed when suddenly thrown into starting your job search journey anew. However, there are simple steps you can take to get you started, ease the transition, and help you in landing your new dream job. At Recruit I.T., we've seen many experienced candidates successfully navigate this path, and we're here to share some valuable advice with you.
Person typing on a laptop with digital interface icons on a dark tech background
By Kaleb Leeming • March 11, 2024
Perspectives from Our Director
Show More